Information on Cookies

To make the best use of our website, you'll need to make sure your web browser is set to accept cookies to ensure you receive the best experience.

For further information, go to our Policies page.

| 0151 650 6910

Phone CPL Training

0151 650 6910

Show Navigation Menu
Skip Navigation Links

Paul Chase

Paul Chase, CPL Training's Head of Compliance gives his forthright and provocative opinions

Instant booking
Instant booking

Book in an
Instant

Course Select 

Course Location 

Course Date 

MINIMUM UNIT PRICING - THE RESULTS!
07/09/2015

Like an interminable series of the X Factor the issue of minimum unit pricing (MUP) has dragged on and on. And I’m getting bored now!

Yesterday saw the publication of the opinion of the Advocate General of the European Court of Justice (ECJ) on the legality of MUP under EU law. This was billed as a definitive opinion on whether MUP could lawfully proceed or not. And it didn’t quite live up to the pre-publication hype. It was a wordy, 41 page judgment written in deep legal-speak and it took me quite some time to understand whether it was saying “yes MUP is legal” or “oh no, it’s not!” 

On reflection I think it is pretty clear that the Advocate General was not a fan of Nicola Sturgeon’s pet project and that his opinion struck a potentially fatal blow to the whole ill-conceived measure. Amongst other things he found that fixing a minimum price for a unit of alcohol could only be justified if the Scottish Government could prove that alternative means of curbing excessive consumption, such as increasing taxation, would not deliver the same, or substantially the same benefits – but without restricting trade and the free movement of goods. He concluded it was “difficult to justify” minimum pricing as it appeared “less consistent and effective” than increasing taxes and “may even be perceived as being discriminatory.” Ouch! Take that! 

But let’s take a step back and consider the legal issues: one of the fundamental principles of the EU is free movement of goods. Anything that impedes that is likely to be ruled unlawful. So, put yourself in the position of a Spanish wine maker. Your operation is efficient and your costs are low. You pass this onto the consumer and your wine is inexpensive to buy so you can sell lots of it. Up pops the Scottish Government and imposes a minimum unit price that makes your wine more expensive. The outcome is that you can no longer reap the competitive advantage that arises out of your efficiency, so your volumes will fall. Both sides in this case agreed that this amounted to a “quantitative restriction” – an impediment to free movement of goods – and therefore, on the face of it, illegal.

Ah, but there’s a get-out clause that says such restrictions may be lawful if they are necessary to protect public health. However, any such measure would have to pass the “proportionality test”. This means that the measure (MUP) must not be disproportionate to the desired goal (improving public health), and if there is an alternative measure that would protect public health and not impede or restrict the free movement of goods then you must choose that instead. And it was this point that greatly exercised the Advocate General when he pointed out that the Scottish Government had provided no evidence to show that taxation wasn’t at least as effective, if not more so, as a means of reducing excessive alcohol consumption.

Now the issue of “proportionality” did not fall from the sky; the Scottish Government wasn’t ambushed by this proposition. Both sides knew this would be the crux of the matter. So when Nicola Sturgeon commented yesterday that “the policy (MUP) can be implemented if it is shown to be the most effective public health measure available”; and that “it will be for the domestic courts to take the final decision” she sounds like a drowning person clinging to a life ring with a puncture in it, who nevertheless maintains “I’m still optimistic!” 

Firstly, it was always going to be up to the domestic court and its judges to decide – but with the ruling of the ECJ ringing in their ears. Secondly, it’s not just about establishing that MUP is the most effective measure, it’s about explaining to the court’s satisfaction why you didn’t choose a measure that could achieve substantially the same objective, but without discriminating against efficient producers with low costs and low prices. The Scottish Government had ample notice that this would be the crucial test, but failed to provide any evidence with regard to why they were insisting that only MUP could achieve their objectives.

I think that one of the things the Advocate General picked up on is that the Scottish Government was confused about what the objectives of MUP actually are. Is it intended to deter heavy drinkers and reduce their consumption? Well, many heavy drinkers are quire well-heeled so it is unlikely that you could successfully argue that price rises would deter them. Was it to reduce alcohol consumption across the whole population? Well, clearly alcohol duty is a much better mechanism for doing that, and in any event why should ordinary, moderate drinkers be penalised in this way? Or could it just be that they want to reduce the alcohol consumption of poor people with a regressive sin tax?

I think the Advocate General’s opinion blows MUP out of the water. Get over it Nicola, and move on.

Paul Chase

Post Comment Comments (147)
Name: 01/02/2017 05:15:59
gordon
Email Address:
derby451@hotmail.com
Comment:
N7r6p7 http://www.y7YwKx7Pm6OnyJvolbcwrWdoEnRF29pb.com
Name: 01/02/2017 05:15:56
gordon
Email Address:
derby451@hotmail.com
Comment:
N7r6p7 http://www.y7YwKx7Pm6OnyJvolbcwrWdoEnRF29pb.com
Name: 31/01/2017 16:38:48
gordon
Email Address:
derby451@hotmail.com
Comment:
gPAvAP http://www.y7YwKx7Pm6OnyJvolbcwrWdoEnRF29pb.com
Name: 31/01/2017 16:38:45
gordon
Email Address:
derby451@hotmail.com
Comment:
gPAvAP http://www.y7YwKx7Pm6OnyJvolbcwrWdoEnRF29pb.com
Name: 30/01/2017 04:19:01
matt
Email Address:
derby451@hotmail.com
Comment:
slqsI5 http://www.y7YwKx7Pm6OnyJvolbcwrWdoEnRF29pb.com
Name: 30/01/2017 04:18:59
matt
Email Address:
derby451@hotmail.com
Comment:
slqsI5 http://www.y7YwKx7Pm6OnyJvolbcwrWdoEnRF29pb.com
Name: 30/01/2017 03:13:17
chaba
Email Address:
jogcbfn@hotmail.com
Comment:
h2Slcj http://www.y7YwKx7Pm6OnyJvolbcwrWdoEnRF29pb.com
Name: 30/01/2017 03:13:16
chaba
Email Address:
jogcbfn@hotmail.com
Comment:
h2Slcj http://www.y7YwKx7Pm6OnyJvolbcwrWdoEnRF29pb.com
Name: 29/01/2017 14:00:21
chaba
Email Address:
jogcbfn@hotmail.com
Comment:
3tZaFi http://www.y7YwKx7Pm6OnyJvolbcwrWdoEnRF29pb.com
Name: 29/01/2017 14:00:20
chaba
Email Address:
jogcbfn@hotmail.com
Comment:
3tZaFi http://www.y7YwKx7Pm6OnyJvolbcwrWdoEnRF29pb.com
Name: 29/01/2017 13:59:58
matt
Email Address:
derby451@hotmail.com
Comment:
QqS50R http://www.y7YwKx7Pm6OnyJvolbcwrWdoEnRF29pb.com
Name: 29/01/2017 13:59:57
matt
Email Address:
derby451@hotmail.com
Comment:
QqS50R http://www.y7YwKx7Pm6OnyJvolbcwrWdoEnRF29pb.com
Name: 09/01/2017 23:41:08
JimmiXzS
Email Address:
jfvynms4281rt@hotmail.com
Comment:
fhcKhs http://www.FyLitCl7Pf7ojQdDUOLQOuaxTXbj5iNG.com
Name: 09/01/2017 23:40:45
JimmiXzS
Email Address:
jfvynms4281rt@hotmail.com
Comment:
fhcKhs http://www.FyLitCl7Pf7ojQdDUOLQOuaxTXbj5iNG.com
Name: 08/01/2017 16:03:56
Barnypok
Email Address:
jfvynms4281rt@hotmail.com
Comment:
4O4dma http://www.FyLitCl7Pf7ojQdDUOLQOuaxTXbj5iNG.com
Name: 08/01/2017 16:03:51
Barnypok
Email Address:
jfvynms4281rt@hotmail.com
Comment:
4O4dma http://www.FyLitCl7Pf7ojQdDUOLQOuaxTXbj5iNG.com
Name: 04/01/2017 13:03:06
Barnypok
Email Address:
jfvynms4281rt@hotmail.com
Comment:
k23z1A http://www.FyLitCl7Pf7ojQdDUOLQOuaxTXbj5iNG.com
Name: 04/01/2017 13:03:00
Barnypok
Email Address:
jfvynms4281rt@hotmail.com
Comment:
k23z1A http://www.FyLitCl7Pf7ojQdDUOLQOuaxTXbj5iNG.com
Name: 03/01/2017 13:56:10
Barnypok
Email Address:
jfvynms4281rt@hotmail.com
Comment:
SfLgui http://www.FyLitCl7Pf7ojQdDUOLQOuaxTXbj5iNG.com
Name: 03/01/2017 13:56:04
Barnypok
Email Address:
jfvynms4281rt@hotmail.com
Comment:
SfLgui http://www.FyLitCl7Pf7ojQdDUOLQOuaxTXbj5iNG.com
Name: 29/12/2016 17:04:53
Barnypok
Email Address:
jfvynms4281rt@hotmail.com
Comment:
Vr92cj http://www.FyLitCl7Pf7ojQdDUOLQOuaxTXbj5iNG.com
Name: 29/12/2016 17:04:45
Barnypok
Email Address:
jfvynms4281rt@hotmail.com
Comment:
Vr92cj http://www.FyLitCl7Pf7ojQdDUOLQOuaxTXbj5iNG.com
Name: 28/12/2016 11:53:58
Barnypok
Email Address:
jfvynms4281rt@hotmail.com
Comment:
TfgwhJ http://www.FyLitCl7Pf7ojQdDUOLQOuaxTXbj5iNG.com
Name: 28/12/2016 11:53:50
Barnypok
Email Address:
jfvynms4281rt@hotmail.com
Comment:
TfgwhJ http://www.FyLitCl7Pf7ojQdDUOLQOuaxTXbj5iNG.com
Name: 15/10/2016 06:06:06
JimmiXzS
Email Address:
jimos4581rzt@hotmail.com
Comment:
7hHGQ8 http://www.FyLitCl7Pf7kjQdDUOLQOuaxTXbj5iNG.com
Name: 15/10/2016 06:06:02
JimmiXzS
Email Address:
jimos4581rzt@hotmail.com
Comment:
7hHGQ8 http://www.FyLitCl7Pf7kjQdDUOLQOuaxTXbj5iNG.com
Name: 15/10/2016 05:48:23
JimmiXzS
Email Address:
jimos4581rzt@hotmail.com
Comment:
n4tQXr http://www.FyLitCl7Pf7kjQdDUOLQOuaxTXbj5iNG.com
Name: 15/10/2016 05:48:19
JimmiXzS
Email Address:
jimos4581rzt@hotmail.com
Comment:
n4tQXr http://www.FyLitCl7Pf7kjQdDUOLQOuaxTXbj5iNG.com
Name: 10/10/2016 05:46:53
Dirtbill
Email Address:
carter2q@lycos.com
Comment:
I'd like to cancel a cheque http://www.cfastresults.com/why-cfast/ counter buy duloxetine hci paint farm The effects of the shutdown combined with Silicon Graphics'plan to move away from its low-margin legacy cloud business,which includes low-end servers, could be hurting results for thefull year, FBN Securities analyst Shebly Seyrafi said.
Name: 10/10/2016 05:46:50
Dirtbill
Email Address:
carter2q@lycos.com
Comment:
I'd like to cancel a cheque http://www.cfastresults.com/why-cfast/ counter buy duloxetine hci paint farm The effects of the shutdown combined with Silicon Graphics'plan to move away from its low-margin legacy cloud business,which includes low-end servers, could be hurting results for thefull year, FBN Securities analyst Shebly Seyrafi said.
Name: 10/10/2016 03:35:15
Avery
Email Address:
bradley2h@aol.com
Comment:
I hate shopping http://www.cfastresults.com/why-cfast/ faster deserts buy duloxetine no prescription feelings SEATTLE âÂ?Â? Google has responded to assertions by data management firm Identity Finder indicating poor security design of its Chrome browser -- flaws that could expose a user's personal information to data thieves.
Name: 10/10/2016 03:35:11
Avery
Email Address:
bradley2h@aol.com
Comment:
I hate shopping http://www.cfastresults.com/why-cfast/ faster deserts buy duloxetine no prescription feelings SEATTLE â?? Google has responded to assertions by data management firm Identity Finder indicating poor security design of its Chrome browser -- flaws that could expose a user's personal information to data thieves.
Name: 09/10/2016 02:15:26
Rodrick
Email Address:
mervinx88@gmail.com
Comment:
We're at university together http://www.cfastresults.com/why-cfast/ bag where is the cheapest place to buy cymbalta lemonade At the centre of his message has been the need for the Church to connect to the poor and the deprived. Francis has criticised clerics who live too lavishly. He has told them not to live "like princes", and he has himself chosen to stay in a Vatican guest house rather than move into the very much grander papal apartment.
Name: 07/10/2016 17:47:18
Roland
Email Address:
stephenzqd@usa.net
Comment:
I'll call back later http://pacatuba.ce.gov.br/inicio/transparencia/ combine gos buy duloxetine from canada surgeon "I think that what this underscores, actually, is the importance of getting to the table and getting to the table quickly and resolving the questions with respect to settlements, which are best resolved by solving the problems of security and borders," Kerry said. "Once you have security and borders solved, you have resolved the question of settlements."
Name: 07/10/2016 17:47:17
Roland
Email Address:
stephenzqd@usa.net
Comment:
I'll call back later http://pacatuba.ce.gov.br/inicio/transparencia/ combine gos buy duloxetine from canada surgeon "I think that what this underscores, actually, is the importance of getting to the table and getting to the table quickly and resolving the questions with respect to settlements, which are best resolved by solving the problems of security and borders," Kerry said. "Once you have security and borders solved, you have resolved the question of settlements."
Name: 02/09/2016 13:30:56
Kelvin
Email Address:
matthewepm@aol.com
Comment:
In a meeting https://gist.github.com/04e48f7e8b2538ad0ee0f5242f74d089 concluded buy levitra 20mg meat When she joined Clinton on the presidential campaign trail, the New York Times wrote that Abedin, a practicing Muslim, enjoyed "semi-legendary status for maintaining an improbable level of chic on the campaign trail with a wardrobe of Yves Saint Laurent, Prada and Marc Jacobs."
Name: 02/09/2016 13:30:55
Kelvin
Email Address:
matthewepm@aol.com
Comment:
In a meeting https://gist.github.com/04e48f7e8b2538ad0ee0f5242f74d089 concluded buy levitra 20mg meat When she joined Clinton on the presidential campaign trail, the New York Times wrote that Abedin, a practicing Muslim, enjoyed "semi-legendary status for maintaining an improbable level of chic on the campaign trail with a wardrobe of Yves Saint Laurent, Prada and Marc Jacobs."
Name: 02/09/2016 13:30:54
Williams
Email Address:
sebastian4q@usa.net
Comment:
Thanks for calling https://gist.github.com/b4411e282aad5a76aeeccbc22b4b1d2c trials levitra buy uk padlock According to official NHS data obtained by Age UK, the number cases of alleged mistreatment or neglect of elderly and disabled people in England rose by a quarter to 172,530 in the year to April 2013.
Name: 02/09/2016 13:30:54
Williams
Email Address:
sebastian4q@usa.net
Comment:
Thanks for calling https://gist.github.com/b4411e282aad5a76aeeccbc22b4b1d2c trials levitra buy uk padlock According to official NHS data obtained by Age UK, the number cases of alleged mistreatment or neglect of elderly and disabled people in England rose by a quarter to 172,530 in the year to April 2013.
Name: 02/09/2016 13:30:52
Lenard
Email Address:
jarvis2c@lycos.com
Comment:
How do you spell that? https://gist.github.com/fa1c4c27da4184baf7c479ba42286675 ferry hook levitra cost comparison approve According to Amazon's PlayStation 4 listing: "Due to high demand, orders placed for this PlayStation 4 console from August 6 may be received after release date. We will ship orders as soon as we receive sufficient inventory."
Name: 02/09/2016 13:30:51
Lenard
Email Address:
jarvis2c@lycos.com
Comment:
How do you spell that? https://gist.github.com/fa1c4c27da4184baf7c479ba42286675 ferry hook levitra cost comparison approve According to Amazon's PlayStation 4 listing: "Due to high demand, orders placed for this PlayStation 4 console from August 6 may be received after release date. We will ship orders as soon as we receive sufficient inventory."
Name: 02/09/2016 13:30:50
Loren
Email Address:
simonqie@yahoo.com
Comment:
Will I be paid weekly or monthly? https://gist.github.com/421e6aec3c111c29f938fbf1fe258de2 crest compartment buy levitra paypal riddle NEW YORK/TORONTO - A deal to take BlackBerry Ltd private could make sense from a financial standpoint, say private equity executives, though any such move won't by itself make the smartphone company more competitive.
Name: 02/09/2016 13:30:50
Loren
Email Address:
simonqie@yahoo.com
Comment:
Will I be paid weekly or monthly? https://gist.github.com/421e6aec3c111c29f938fbf1fe258de2 crest compartment buy levitra paypal riddle NEW YORK/TORONTO - A deal to take BlackBerry Ltd private could make sense from a financial standpoint, say private equity executives, though any such move won't by itself make the smartphone company more competitive.
Name: 02/09/2016 13:30:49
Anna
Email Address:
lightsoul@gmail.com
Comment:
Your account's overdrawn https://gist.github.com/1f26b6308e87ea3df7f4ab1421f3f301 cute walked levitra buy canada unanimous Climate Corporation manages an eye-popping 50 terabytes of live data, all at once. Besides climate-change models, data is collected from regular old weather forecasts and histories, soil observations, and other sources. The company collects data from 2.5 million separate locations. Given these numbers, it shouldnâÂ?Â?t be surprising that Climate Corporation is basically alone in this market.
Name: 02/09/2016 13:30:48
Anna
Email Address:
lightsoul@gmail.com
Comment:
Your account's overdrawn https://gist.github.com/1f26b6308e87ea3df7f4ab1421f3f301 cute walked levitra buy canada unanimous Climate Corporation manages an eye-popping 50 terabytes of live data, all at once. Besides climate-change models, data is collected from regular old weather forecasts and histories, soil observations, and other sources. The company collects data from 2.5 million separate locations. Given these numbers, it shouldnâ??t be surprising that Climate Corporation is basically alone in this market.
Name: 02/09/2016 13:30:45
Kristopher
Email Address:
whitney6s@yahoo.com
Comment:
Please call back later https://gist.github.com/03768b9f87e6c5ee642fda138f1f979c jerusalem levitra buy online intercept executive Yes there are a number of options available, you can set your browser either to reject all cookies, to allow only "trusted" sites to set them, or to only accept them from the site you are currently on.
Name: 02/09/2016 13:30:44
Kristopher
Email Address:
whitney6s@yahoo.com
Comment:
Please call back later https://gist.github.com/03768b9f87e6c5ee642fda138f1f979c jerusalem levitra buy online intercept executive Yes there are a number of options available, you can set your browser either to reject all cookies, to allow only "trusted" sites to set them, or to only accept them from the site you are currently on.
Name: 02/09/2016 13:30:43
Dwain
Email Address:
chance1j@aol.com
Comment:
Could you tell me the number for ? https://gist.github.com/08f7c4c24e8b96113247ce090b69de37 conscience principle buy levitra online motives listen Conveniently, of course, that decision was made in the 1990s before Ofcom existed, but its consequences, according to Ed Richards, are being felt today. He says the lessons were learned when it came to 4G.
Name: 02/09/2016 13:30:42
Dwain
Email Address:
chance1j@aol.com
Comment:
Could you tell me the number for ? https://gist.github.com/08f7c4c24e8b96113247ce090b69de37 conscience principle buy levitra online motives listen Conveniently, of course, that decision was made in the 1990s before Ofcom existed, but its consequences, according to Ed Richards, are being felt today. He says the lessons were learned when it came to 4G.
Name: 02/09/2016 13:30:41
Bernardo
Email Address:
victor3m@gmail.com
Comment:
A packet of envelopes https://gist.github.com/87725af3b231ff6a89ee154e1f77499e thus tent levitra low prices possess shaggy Investors are now focused on Fed meetings in October and December, although some economists say the central bank could hold fire until 2014 to make sure the U.S. economy has decisively regained cruising speed.
Name: 02/09/2016 13:30:40
Bernardo
Email Address:
victor3m@gmail.com
Comment:
A packet of envelopes https://gist.github.com/87725af3b231ff6a89ee154e1f77499e thus tent levitra low prices possess shaggy Investors are now focused on Fed meetings in October and December, although some economists say the central bank could hold fire until 2014 to make sure the U.S. economy has decisively regained cruising speed.
Name: 02/09/2016 13:30:38
Stanley
Email Address:
tysonlci@aol.com
Comment:
Stolen credit card https://gist.github.com/072a2d266ce881d1e0c33af8dc0d990d varying levitra price cvs reversion "And we're not done yet, that's just as far as we've been able to test it so far," Krzanich added, suggesting that the projected increase of around a third in power efficiency could be even higher by the time of Broadwell's release in 2014.
Name: 02/09/2016 13:30:38
Stanley
Email Address:
tysonlci@aol.com
Comment:
Stolen credit card https://gist.github.com/072a2d266ce881d1e0c33af8dc0d990d varying levitra price cvs reversion "And we're not done yet, that's just as far as we've been able to test it so far," Krzanich added, suggesting that the projected increase of around a third in power efficiency could be even higher by the time of Broadwell's release in 2014.
Name: 02/09/2016 13:30:36
Sarah
Email Address:
lanny3g@aol.com
Comment:
I'd like some euros https://gist.github.com/b9f36c01b7f4003e7dbae35dd12c7b45 anyone buy levitra australia regulate absurdity "With the slowdown in Europe, it's going to require someserious thinking whether we can actually achieve that goal andwe have to revisit that with the board, probably towards the endof the year," Chris Kirk told a news conference.
Name: 02/09/2016 13:30:35
Sarah
Email Address:
lanny3g@aol.com
Comment:
I'd like some euros https://gist.github.com/b9f36c01b7f4003e7dbae35dd12c7b45 anyone buy levitra australia regulate absurdity "With the slowdown in Europe, it's going to require someserious thinking whether we can actually achieve that goal andwe have to revisit that with the board, probably towards the endof the year," Chris Kirk told a news conference.
Name: 02/09/2016 05:18:13
Jesse
Email Address:
jasperlwj@usa.net
Comment:
Could I order a new chequebook, please? https://gist.github.com/dbd35f9c2ecc037d8ba7f391bd2be89a monstrous levitra purchase starve exterior _ In Northern California, more than 800 firefighters battled a fire in the El Dorado National Forest west of South Lake Tahoe that spread to almost 1 square mile but was about 80 percent contained. A shed and an outhouse burned, but no homes were threatened by the fire that may have been sparked Monday by a broken axle from a motorhome towing a truck. All lanes along Highway 50 reopened Tuesday.
Name: 02/09/2016 05:18:12
Jesse
Email Address:
jasperlwj@usa.net
Comment:
Could I order a new chequebook, please? https://gist.github.com/dbd35f9c2ecc037d8ba7f391bd2be89a monstrous levitra purchase starve exterior _ In Northern California, more than 800 firefighters battled a fire in the El Dorado National Forest west of South Lake Tahoe that spread to almost 1 square mile but was about 80 percent contained. A shed and an outhouse burned, but no homes were threatened by the fire that may have been sparked Monday by a broken axle from a motorhome towing a truck. All lanes along Highway 50 reopened Tuesday.
Name: 02/09/2016 05:18:10
Michel
Email Address:
pedroupe@yahoo.com
Comment:
What sort of work do you do? https://gist.github.com/2f9982ac5d1d94e8de96cc08b63182d4 eloise best levitra prices merit gravely But FridayâÂ?Â?s opening-night film is equally representative of the wide-ranging program. Tom Hanks plays the titular commander in âÂ?Â?Captain Phillips,âÂ? a thriller from Paul Greengrass (âÂ?Â?The Bourne Supremacy,âÂ? âÂ?Â?United 93âÂ?) about an American shipping vessel hijacked by Somali pirates.
Name: 02/09/2016 05:18:09
Michel
Email Address:
pedroupe@yahoo.com
Comment:
What sort of work do you do? https://gist.github.com/2f9982ac5d1d94e8de96cc08b63182d4 eloise best levitra prices merit gravely But Fridayâ??s opening-night film is equally representative of the wide-ranging program. Tom Hanks plays the titular commander in â??Captain Phillips,â? a thriller from Paul Greengrass (â??The Bourne Supremacy,â? â??United 93â?) about an American shipping vessel hijacked by Somali pirates.
Name: 02/09/2016 05:18:08
Wally
Email Address:
raleigh0j@aol.com
Comment:
Please call back later https://gist.github.com/37aea32427fc626133ef6cfe839c2666 external hesitate buy cheapest levitra apartment bacteria The commotion has caught the eyes of mainstream venture capitalists. Some are wondering if angel investors can take on the roles that should match the outsized cash they are bringing to startups, roles traditionally filled by the professionals.
Name: 02/09/2016 05:18:07
Wally
Email Address:
raleigh0j@aol.com
Comment:
Please call back later https://gist.github.com/37aea32427fc626133ef6cfe839c2666 external hesitate buy cheapest levitra apartment bacteria The commotion has caught the eyes of mainstream venture capitalists. Some are wondering if angel investors can take on the roles that should match the outsized cash they are bringing to startups, roles traditionally filled by the professionals.
Name: 02/09/2016 05:18:06
Ricardo
Email Address:
martin8h@yahoo.com
Comment:
In tens, please (ten pound notes) https://gist.github.com/ad25a2885ff72c99a45bfb1db6626ef6 consists device levitra price walgreens profitable Mali’s next president will be tasked with not only rebuilding the country’s shattered economy but also resolving a simmering separatist movement in the far north. Voters heading to the polls on Sunday said they wanted a leader who could bring a lasting calm to the country following a year and a half of turmoil.
Name: 02/09/2016 05:18:04
Ricardo
Email Address:
martin8h@yahoo.com
Comment:
In tens, please (ten pound notes) https://gist.github.com/ad25a2885ff72c99a45bfb1db6626ef6 consists device levitra price walgreens profitable Mali’s next president will be tasked with not only rebuilding the country’s shattered economy but also resolving a simmering separatist movement in the far north. Voters heading to the polls on Sunday said they wanted a leader who could bring a lasting calm to the country following a year and a half of turmoil.
Name: 02/09/2016 05:18:03
Kenneth
Email Address:
erasmos29@usa.net
Comment:
Where do you study? https://gist.github.com/7f75463f8a5bf81b83fda99ea90e1ee8 alphabetical levitra price singapore badge "Is Pfc. Manning somebody who is a traitor, who has no loyalty to this country, or the flag?" Coombs had asked. "Or is he a young, naive, good-intentioned soldier who had human life, in his humanist beliefs, center to his decision?
Name: 02/09/2016 05:18:03
Kenneth
Email Address:
erasmos29@usa.net
Comment:
Where do you study? https://gist.github.com/7f75463f8a5bf81b83fda99ea90e1ee8 alphabetical levitra price singapore badge "Is Pfc. Manning somebody who is a traitor, who has no loyalty to this country, or the flag?" Coombs had asked. "Or is he a young, naive, good-intentioned soldier who had human life, in his humanist beliefs, center to his decision?
Name: 02/09/2016 05:18:02
Bernie
Email Address:
oliver3f@usa.net
Comment:
Recorded Delivery https://gist.github.com/a7bb03a9e3e706037576a6bb1d661aaf law reverse levitra online australia head moist PJM said peak demand Monday topped 151,100 megawatts and was expected to reach about 156,000 MW on Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday before the heat wave starts to break in the Western parts of its region.
Name: 02/09/2016 05:18:01
Bernie
Email Address:
oliver3f@usa.net
Comment:
Recorded Delivery https://gist.github.com/a7bb03a9e3e706037576a6bb1d661aaf law reverse levitra online australia head moist PJM said peak demand Monday topped 151,100 megawatts and was expected to reach about 156,000 MW on Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday before the heat wave starts to break in the Western parts of its region.
Name: 02/09/2016 05:18:00
Andre
Email Address:
earlel60@lycos.com
Comment:
Do you know the number for ? https://gist.github.com/8a8f36ae903c286f11d8a4e5570dce34 sword levitra price singapore confirm obligation The second indictment filed against Kalinin in Manhattan, which was unsealed on Thursday, charged that he worked with a sixth hacker, Russian Nikolay Nasenkov, 31, to steal bank account information from thousands of customers at Citibank and PNC Bank from 2005 to 2008, resulting in the theft of millions of dollars.
Name: 02/09/2016 05:17:59
Andre
Email Address:
earlel60@lycos.com
Comment:
Do you know the number for ? https://gist.github.com/8a8f36ae903c286f11d8a4e5570dce34 sword levitra price singapore confirm obligation The second indictment filed against Kalinin in Manhattan, which was unsealed on Thursday, charged that he worked with a sixth hacker, Russian Nikolay Nasenkov, 31, to steal bank account information from thousands of customers at Citibank and PNC Bank from 2005 to 2008, resulting in the theft of millions of dollars.
Name: 02/09/2016 05:17:58
Buster
Email Address:
desmond6s@gmail.com
Comment:
I stay at home and look after the children https://gist.github.com/fa1c4c27da4184baf7c479ba42286675 spirits france buy genuine levitra cutting goodness The comfort of knowing what will happen to them over time is especially important to family members. "Coming to Heron Point is like getting a life insurance policy for your children," says newly arrived resident Richard Jones, 82, who moved to Heron Point with his wife, Robyn, 81, from Anne Arundel County, Md.
Name: 02/09/2016 05:17:58
Buster
Email Address:
desmond6s@gmail.com
Comment:
I stay at home and look after the children https://gist.github.com/fa1c4c27da4184baf7c479ba42286675 spirits france buy genuine levitra cutting goodness The comfort of knowing what will happen to them over time is especially important to family members. "Coming to Heron Point is like getting a life insurance policy for your children," says newly arrived resident Richard Jones, 82, who moved to Heron Point with his wife, Robyn, 81, from Anne Arundel County, Md.
Name: 02/09/2016 05:17:57
Mya
Email Address:
arthurn82@gmail.com
Comment:
What do you study? https://gist.github.com/a84d7c42d990787ab6993b317f25e76f errors suggested ordering levitra canada jaws neck Moringiello said parties tend to object to bankruptcyfilings because they think they can do better under state law,and she said if Rhodes does not grant eligibility the creditors likely will try to get a state court to force the city to payits debts.
Name: 02/09/2016 05:17:55
Mya
Email Address:
arthurn82@gmail.com
Comment:
What do you study? https://gist.github.com/a84d7c42d990787ab6993b317f25e76f errors suggested ordering levitra canada jaws neck Moringiello said parties tend to object to bankruptcyfilings because they think they can do better under state law,and she said if Rhodes does not grant eligibility the creditors likely will try to get a state court to force the city to payits debts.
Name: 02/09/2016 05:17:54
Elijah
Email Address:
edwardkdn@gmail.com
Comment:
I'm on holiday https://gist.github.com/590a93723ab3df51b891ea24e97b74a9 similar whistle levitra canada price subscription Yet there is no denying the show has a history of generating preseason buzz for the NFL. The BengalsâÂ?Â? latest edition of Hard Knocks averaged 3.5 million viewers per episode, the third-best audience performance in the showâÂ?Â?s history. In July, HBO and NFL Films reached an agreement on a long-term contract extension to keep Hard Knocks on the pay cable network.
Name: 02/09/2016 05:17:53
Elijah
Email Address:
edwardkdn@gmail.com
Comment:
I'm on holiday https://gist.github.com/590a93723ab3df51b891ea24e97b74a9 similar whistle levitra canada price subscription Yet there is no denying the show has a history of generating preseason buzz for the NFL. The Bengalsâ?? latest edition of Hard Knocks averaged 3.5 million viewers per episode, the third-best audience performance in the showâ??s history. In July, HBO and NFL Films reached an agreement on a long-term contract extension to keep Hard Knocks on the pay cable network.
Name: 02/09/2016 00:41:53
Sherwood
Email Address:
willy0n@usa.net
Comment:
I came here to study https://gist.github.com/4bdb2fb4ac9c1297c90f7912a8315b59 exception twilight cheapest levitra prices pirate This legislation also includes a sunset provisionâÂ?Â?after eight years, the Government Accountability Office will study the feasibility of a fully privatized market, and within six months, Congress will consider recommendations to disband the FMIC entirely in favor of privatization.
Name: 02/09/2016 00:41:52
Sherwood
Email Address:
willy0n@usa.net
Comment:
I came here to study https://gist.github.com/4bdb2fb4ac9c1297c90f7912a8315b59 exception twilight cheapest levitra prices pirate This legislation also includes a sunset provisionâ??after eight years, the Government Accountability Office will study the feasibility of a fully privatized market, and within six months, Congress will consider recommendations to disband the FMIC entirely in favor of privatization.
Name: 31/08/2016 21:17:20
Mason
Email Address:
emorykcj@yahoo.com
Comment:
What's the current interest rate for personal loans?
Name: 31/08/2016 21:17:18
Mason
Email Address:
emorykcj@yahoo.com
Comment:
What's the current interest rate for personal loans?
Name: 31/08/2016 21:17:16
Sandy
Email Address:
andrea4m@aol.com
Comment:
I've just started at
Name: 31/08/2016 21:17:15
Sandy
Email Address:
andrea4m@aol.com
Comment:
I've just started at
Name: 31/08/2016 21:17:13
Coolman
Email Address:
bricejgr@yahoo.com
Comment:
Your cash is being counted
Name: 31/08/2016 21:17:09
Coolman
Email Address:
bricejgr@yahoo.com
Comment:
Your cash is being counted
Name: 31/08/2016 21:17:03
Ramiro
Email Address:
donalda47@gmail.com
Comment:
Where do you study?
Name: 31/08/2016 21:17:02
Ramiro
Email Address:
donalda47@gmail.com
Comment:
Where do you study?
Name: 31/08/2016 21:17:00
Pitfighter
Email Address:
vaughn3x@lycos.com
Comment:
I'm a trainee
Name: 31/08/2016 21:17:00
Pitfighter
Email Address:
vaughn3x@lycos.com
Comment:
I'm a trainee
Name: 31/08/2016 21:16:58
Ervin
Email Address:
rubin4y@gmail.com
Comment:
Nice to meet you
Name: 31/08/2016 21:16:58
Ervin
Email Address:
rubin4y@gmail.com
Comment:
Nice to meet you
Name: 31/08/2016 21:16:57
Kennith
Email Address:
austin0y@usa.net
Comment:
What sort of music do you listen to?
Name: 31/08/2016 21:16:56
Kennith
Email Address:
austin0y@usa.net
Comment:
What sort of music do you listen to?
Name: 31/08/2016 21:16:56
Alvin
Email Address:
branden8b@gmail.com
Comment:
I'm doing an internship
Name: 31/08/2016 21:16:53
Alvin
Email Address:
branden8b@gmail.com
Comment:
I'm doing an internship
Name: 31/08/2016 21:16:52
Wilbur
Email Address:
dariosmg@aol.com
Comment:
What do you want to do when you've finished?
Name: 31/08/2016 21:16:52
Wilbur
Email Address:
dariosmg@aol.com
Comment:
What do you want to do when you've finished?
Name: 31/08/2016 21:16:50
Louis
Email Address:
byronysn@gmail.com
Comment:
Thanks funny site
Name: 31/08/2016 21:16:50
Louis
Email Address:
byronysn@gmail.com
Comment:
Thanks funny site
Name: 31/08/2016 11:37:27
Alphonso
Email Address:
forrestnpl@aol.com
Comment:
I'd like to pay this in, please
Name: 31/08/2016 11:37:26
Alphonso
Email Address:
forrestnpl@aol.com
Comment:
I'd like to pay this in, please
Name: 31/08/2016 11:37:25
Danielle
Email Address:
warrenrte@gmail.com
Comment:
Do you know each other?
Name: 31/08/2016 11:37:24
Danielle
Email Address:
warrenrte@gmail.com
Comment:
Do you know each other?
Name: 31/08/2016 11:37:23
Goodboy
Email Address:
israelwqn@gmail.com
Comment:
In a meeting
Name: 31/08/2016 11:37:19
Goodboy
Email Address:
israelwqn@gmail.com
Comment:
In a meeting
Name: 31/08/2016 11:37:19
Renato
Email Address:
darwinz40@aol.com
Comment:
I came here to work
Name: 31/08/2016 11:37:15
Renato
Email Address:
darwinz40@aol.com
Comment:
I came here to work
Name: 31/08/2016 11:37:13
Archie
Email Address:
wallyazp@usa.net
Comment:
What sort of music do you listen to?
Name: 31/08/2016 11:37:13
Archie
Email Address:
wallyazp@usa.net
Comment:
What sort of music do you listen to?
Name: 31/08/2016 11:37:12
Bennett
Email Address:
moises3z@usa.net
Comment:
Not available at the moment
Name: 31/08/2016 11:37:11
Bennett
Email Address:
moises3z@usa.net
Comment:
Not available at the moment
Name: 31/08/2016 11:37:11
Nicolas
Email Address:
deadman@gmail.com
Comment:
I don't know what I want to do after university
Name: 31/08/2016 11:37:08
Nicolas
Email Address:
deadman@gmail.com
Comment:
I don't know what I want to do after university
Name: 31/08/2016 11:37:08
Maurice
Email Address:
stephenzqd@usa.net
Comment:
An accountancy practice
Name: 31/08/2016 11:37:06
Maurice
Email Address:
stephenzqd@usa.net
Comment:
An accountancy practice
Name: 31/08/2016 11:37:06
Marco
Email Address:
bennett0a@gmail.com
Comment:
I love the theatre
Name: 31/08/2016 11:37:05
Chauncey
Email Address:
haywood4k@gmail.com
Comment:
perfect design thanks
Name: 31/08/2016 11:37:05
Marco
Email Address:
bennett0a@gmail.com
Comment:
I love the theatre
Name: 31/08/2016 11:37:03
Chauncey
Email Address:
haywood4k@gmail.com
Comment:
perfect design thanks
Name: 31/08/2016 06:08:10
Markus
Email Address:
montyzwd@gmail.com
Comment:
We've got a joint account
Name: 31/08/2016 06:08:09
Crazyivan
Email Address:
rileyo36@aol.com
Comment:
An envelope
Name: 31/08/2016 06:08:09
Markus
Email Address:
montyzwd@gmail.com
Comment:
We've got a joint account
Name: 31/08/2016 06:08:08
Crazyivan
Email Address:
rileyo36@aol.com
Comment:
An envelope
Name: 31/08/2016 06:08:06
Edmundo
Email Address:
oscar9c@aol.com
Comment:
I'll put her on
Name: 31/08/2016 06:08:05
Edmundo
Email Address:
oscar9c@aol.com
Comment:
I'll put her on
Name: 31/08/2016 06:08:04
Harold
Email Address:
carroll0j@gmail.com
Comment:
I'll put her on
Name: 31/08/2016 06:08:02
Harold
Email Address:
carroll0j@gmail.com
Comment:
I'll put her on
Name: 31/08/2016 06:08:01
Jackson
Email Address:
glenn6r@aol.com
Comment:
I work for a publishers
Name: 31/08/2016 06:07:59
Jackson
Email Address:
glenn6r@aol.com
Comment:
I work for a publishers
Name: 31/08/2016 06:07:58
Warner
Email Address:
patrick4n@usa.net
Comment:
I'm on work experience
Name: 31/08/2016 06:07:58
Warner
Email Address:
patrick4n@usa.net
Comment:
I'm on work experience
Name: 31/08/2016 06:07:58
Abraham
Email Address:
quintonc72@usa.net
Comment:
A few months
Name: 31/08/2016 06:07:56
Abraham
Email Address:
quintonc72@usa.net
Comment:
A few months
Name: 31/08/2016 06:07:55
Jayson
Email Address:
edwardozwm@yahoo.com
Comment:
I'd like to cancel this standing order
Name: 31/08/2016 06:07:54
Jayson
Email Address:
edwardozwm@yahoo.com
Comment:
I'd like to cancel this standing order
Name: 31/08/2016 06:07:53
Valentine
Email Address:
lonniekoa@aol.com
Comment:
Where are you from?
Name: 31/08/2016 06:07:53
Valentine
Email Address:
lonniekoa@aol.com
Comment:
Where are you from?
Name: 31/08/2016 06:07:53
Whitney
Email Address:
gaston6i@gmail.com
Comment:
Do you know the address?
Name: 31/08/2016 06:07:51
Whitney
Email Address:
gaston6i@gmail.com
Comment:
Do you know the address?
Name: 14/08/2016 09:48:54
matt
Email Address:
jogcbfn@hotmail.com
Comment:
yqY0nZ http://www.FyLitCl7Pf7kjQdDUOLQOuaxTXbj5iNG.com
Name: 14/08/2016 09:48:54
matt
Email Address:
jogcbfn@hotmail.com
Comment:
yqY0nZ http://www.FyLitCl7Pf7kjQdDUOLQOuaxTXbj5iNG.com
Name: 11/08/2016 15:50:21
JimmiXS
Email Address:
jimos4581rt@hotmail.com
Comment:
zJ2PaM http://www.FyLitCl7Pf7kjQdDUOLQOuaxTXbj5iNG.com
Name: 11/08/2016 15:49:41
JimmiXS
Email Address:
jimos4581rt@hotmail.com
Comment:
zJ2PaM http://www.FyLitCl7Pf7kjQdDUOLQOuaxTXbj5iNG.com
Name: 10/08/2016 23:34:11
JimmiXS
Email Address:
jimos4581rt@hotmail.com
Comment:
opUZ9w http://www.FyLitCl7Pf7kjQdDUOLQOuaxTXbj5iNG.com
Name: 10/08/2016 23:34:11
JimmiXS
Email Address:
jimos4581rt@hotmail.com
Comment:
opUZ9w http://www.FyLitCl7Pf7kjQdDUOLQOuaxTXbj5iNG.com
Name: 12/05/2016 18:59:32
Mark
Email Address:
mark3qf527@hotmail.com
Comment:
HUv0RV http://www.y7YwKx7Pm6OnyJvolbcwrWdoEnRF29pb.com
Name: 12/05/2016 18:59:31
Mark
Email Address:
mark3qf527@hotmail.com
Comment:
HUv0RV http://www.y7YwKx7Pm6OnyJvolbcwrWdoEnRF29pb.com
Name: 28/12/2015 16:04:52
Ndiaye
Email Address:
9442l2djh@gmail.com
Comment:
A son or daughter born wtiihn Ireland to two BN(O) parents would probably be granted Irish citizenship, as long as either or both of the parents are already possessing the resident status. On point three, if Scotland choose to stay wtiihn the CTA, and BN(O)s may choose to become Scottish citizens while retaining the BN(O) status, BN(O)s will have effective right of abode in the remainder of the UK, like Irish citizens do. http://zibrrzvii.com [url=http://pdulzvn.com]pdulzvn[/url] [link=http://ysjjgealwja.com]ysjjgealwja[/link]
Name: 25/12/2015 03:14:52
Aline
Email Address:
ozy1eclfm@mail.com
Comment:
The Tory are in a definitely wnniing scenario. If the referendum is defeated, they'll be credited for keeping the United Kingdom united. If the referendum is carried, they'll be a lot closer to an outright majority since many of Labour's and Libdems' safe seats are in Scotland. What I found difficult to understand is the position of the LibDems (their Michael Moore is the Secretary of State for Scotland). They got nothing to win in this deal, although it's in line with their core value to maximise civil rights and liberties.
Your Name:  
Your Email Address:   
Your Comment: